Thursday, July 26, 2007

Best moustache-twirling

Booking Through Thursday

Well, after last week’s record-breaking number of responses (92 last time I checked–an all-time BTT record), I was tempted to use this week’s question to ask what you all thought about Harry Potter 7–but since a decent proportion of you weren’t going to be reading it at all, that seemed unfair. So instead . . .

Who’s the worst fictional villain you can think of? As in, the one you hate the most, find the most evil, are happiest to see defeated? Not the cardboard, two-dimensional variety, but the most deliciously-written, most entertaining, best villain? Not necessarily the most “evil,” so much as the best-conceived on the part of the author…oh, you know what I mean!



This is a difficult one to answer - there are so many candidates. A currently topical one is Voldemort. Then there are Dracula (Bram Stoker), Mr Hyde (Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde), Richard the Third (Shakespeare), Sauron (Lord of the Rings), Hannibal Lecter (Silence of the Lambs) and Jack Torrance (The Shining).

Of these I think the most evil, the one I'd be happiest to see defeated it would have to be Hannibal Lecter, with Jack Torrance running a close second - or even a dead heat. I haven't actually read Silence of the Lambs, but Anthony Hopkins was at his most chilling as Hannibal. I have read The Shining and found Jack to be a scary, evil character but that was nothing to Jack Nicholson's performance in the film - even though I knew the story it really shocked me.

The most deliciously-written, most entertaining, best villain is probably Richard the Third - I think this is because of the RSC performance I saw at Stratford with Henry Goodman as Richard. He was the most believable hunchback and brought Shakespeare's words to life.

Not necessarily the most “evil,” so much as the best-conceived on the part of the author is again Richard the Third. Richard is a fascinating character and opinion is divided on whether he did really kill his nephews. Two books on this subject are The Daughter of Time by Josephine Tey,a novel in which Grant, a policeman in hospital exercises his mind in reviewing the evidence; and The Princes in the Tower by Alison Weir in which she studied the contemporary accounts as well as modern works and eventually concluding that Richard did murder the two princes.

4 comments:

Cee Cee said...

Hannibal oh Hannibal!

Stephanie said...

Most definitely Hannibal!

I loved The Daughter of Time! I read it last year on vacation and thought it was fantastic!

Happy Thursday!

Merri said...

Wasn't the Daughter of Time fantastic?
I love Josephine Tey's works..

Ted said...

Quilp in The Old Curiosity Shop is, hands down, the nastiest, ugliest, unrepentant, most dastardly villain ever to haunt a novel. Especially considering the saintliness of his prey.